What does it actually feel like to go viral before you’re ready? To hit a million signups in three and a half months, watch it all unravel, and then one night find yourself sitting in the bottom of a shower just crying? In this episode of The Tyler Dickerhoof Show, I sit down with Tyler to go through the full arc: the early days at Cornell, the crash, the rebuild, and the growth philosophy I’ve developed across 17 years and over 100 million users. This one gets personal.
From Cornell to the App Store Gold Rush
My curiosity about how humans connect started before I even graduated. At Cornell, I was just trying to figure out how to meet people and find potential mates, and that question never really left me. When Facebook opened its developer platform, I saw an opportunity: what if you could meet friends-of-friends who were single through a common connection, instead of meeting at a bar or on a clunky dating site? That idea eventually became the company I’ve spent the better part of my career building.
The early App Store days were a gold rush. If you staked out your category early, you had a massive advantage because of the influx of users and lack of quality competitors. We’ve seen that same dynamic play out in the past two years with AI. The window of easy wins closes fast, and what’s left is the hard work of actually understanding your users.
The Viral Moment That Almost Broke Me
The biggest mistake I made early on was putting something out there that was so viral that we were not ready to scale the experience. What started as a drunken side project took off overnight: 10,000 users joining a day in the first week. We hit a million signups in three and a half months. It felt incredible, right up until it didn’t.
I was being interviewed by press, running around Silicon Valley, everyone was excited. It was a huge ego boost. But I was chasing vanity metrics instead of focusing on user quality and success, and that eventually led to a collapse in our ability to fundraise our second round. When the shine wore off and the investor meetings dried up, it hit my self-belief hard. One night I found myself sitting in the bottom of my shower, hot water beating down on my head, just crying. Demotivated and lost.
The Mirror-Shattering Moment
Too much of my value at that time was tied to others’ impressions of me. I call it a mirror-shattering moment: it forces you to look at who you really are and what your ego is actually attached to. Processing those emotions, I realised I needed to reconnect to my internal values and find trusted people who could hold up a non-broken mirror.
My first value is putting yourself out there. As an entrepreneur, you have to risk whatever you think you have. The second is resilience. My mom passed away when I was 19, while I was at Cornell. Surviving that taught me I could survive anything. The third is authenticity. Being who I am attracts the right people, and our brand reflects that: unabashed and unafraid, no corporate legal-speak.
Leaving the Bubble
I needed to get out of the San Francisco tech bubble entirely. I sold everything. My car was serendipitously stolen, so I didn’t have to deal with that part. I ended up in Central America, learning Spanish by day and writing code at night. It helped me touch grass again and reconnect with myself as a person and a lifelong learner. Sometimes the most productive thing you can do is completely change your environment.
Selling the Company, Buying It Back, and Growing It the Right Way
I eventually sold the startup. Two and a half years later, I bought it back and revived it from the dead. Now it’s growing better than ever. When we brought it back, the entire principle was sustainable growth. We no longer have investors to answer to, no pressure to become a unicorn. We still grow 50 to 90 percent every year, but it’s built on a foundation that isn’t a house of cards.
Inside larger companies, the pressure to grow quarter-over-quarter leads to shortcuts, short-term thinking, and burnout. The foundation we’ve built now is psychology: understanding ourselves as a team and truly understanding our customers. Our top KPIs are based on user success and satisfaction, not revenue first.
Success vs. Significance
Someone recently pushed me to still think about a billion-dollar exit. My answer was that what’s most significant to me is having a positive impact I can be proud of. Success is when you add value to yourself. Significance is when you add value to others. Kudos are not the same thing as impact.
Empathy and Vulnerability as a Founder’s Superpower
The most important pillar in everything I’ve built is empathy. Not sympathy, but truly connecting with and understanding how other people feel. It applies to fundraising, recruiting, and building for users. Once I genuinely empathised with my business partner’s mind and leadership style, our ability to operate together completely accelerated.
Vulnerability is the other side of that. When I share my free-flow thoughts and insecurities with people, it becomes a magnet for them to share their own. Once you name your fears, they stop feeling like weapons that can be used against you. Being vulnerable is a superpower, not a liability.
How I Stay Grounded
Meditation, gratitude, journaling, and an annual retreat where I return to quiet solace and check in on where my ego might be leading me astray. I used to avoid that kind of reflection because I was scared of what I might find. Now I look forward to it, even when it’s hard. Admitting you need to evaluate yourself is a growth mindset, not a weakness.
Take It Further
Everything we covered in this conversation goes deeper in my book Outrageous Startup Growth, out April 13th. If any of this resonated, that’s where to go next.
Listen on your favorite platform: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube